Claims Evaluation

The Unbiased Edge: Why Independent Claims Evaluation Saves Time, Cost, and Credibility

In a construction dispute, perception can cloud facts—and that’s a dangerous place to build a strategy. Claims evaluation, when done internally or in haste, often leans toward one party’s assumptions, introducing bias, inconsistency, and risk. That’s why truly effective claims resolution begins with an independent, objective evaluation.

At PAR Advisory, we approach Claims Evaluation as both a technical and commercial safeguard. We provide the clarity you need to determine whether a claim should be pursued, resisted, or restructured—and how to do so from a position of strength.

⸻

What Claims Evaluation Really Means

Claims Evaluation isn’t just a review—it’s an investigation, a validation, and in many cases, a strategic reset. We examine each component of the claim through three lenses:

1. Contractual Entitlement

• Does the claim align with the contract terms, notice provisions, and procedural steps?

2. Factual Validity

• Are the events described supported by contemporaneous records? Were they documented properly?

3. Technical and Commercial Merit

• Is the delay causally linked to the event? Are the prolongation costs justifiable?

Does the claim reflect actual impact?

We don’t just confirm or reject—we identify weaknesses, recommend restructuring, and even provide an exposure range for time and cost to support negotiation positioning.

⸻The Strategic Value of an Independent Opinion

An objective claim evaluation provides immediate tactical advantages:

• Avoids escalation by identifying and correcting weak claims before submission

• Strengthens credibility by demonstrating internal due diligence or third-party neutrality

• Improves negotiation outcomes by quantifying realistic entitlements and risks

• Supports legal counsel with clear, well-organized technical foundations for arguments

In high-value projects, it’s not uncommon for one weak claim to trigger a spiral of mistrust, defensive posturing, and contractual breakdowns. A well-timed evaluation breaks that cycle with clarity.

⸻

Our Approach at PAR Advisory

We bring a forensic eye and commercial mindset to every evaluation. Typical deliverables include:

• Detailed evaluation reports or liability briefs for internal or external use

• Risk-rated summaries of exposure (time and cost)

• Recommendations for resubmission, counterclaims, or mitigation

• Advisory support for negotiations or dispute boards

Our reports are structured, practical, and contractually sound—ready to support your position in front of clients, consultants, or tribunals.

⸻

Get Clarity Before You Commit

Before you submit a claim, respond to one, or take a position in negotiation—get an expert opinion that stands up to scrutiny. At PAR Advisory, we provide clear, independent evaluations that reduce risk, save time, and put you in control.

Request your confidential claim evaluation today.

Speak to an advisor